SteamyShelf
Search title, author, trope⌘KSign inSign up
If you loved

Books like Rachel's Pudding Pantry (Pudding Pantry, Book 1).

Inspired by Caroline Roberts

Romance readers who clicked with Rachel's Pudding Pantry (Pudding Pantry, Book 1) by Caroline Roberts often reach for these next. The list is ranked by how many tropes each book shares with the original, so the further down you scroll, the looser the connection.

A holiday to remember
A holiday to remember
Brittany Young
3 shared
A Regency Christmas I
A Regency Christmas I
Mary Balogh, Gayle Buck, Edith Layton
3 shared
A Wedding at the Comfort Food Cafe
A Wedding at the Comfort Food Cafe
Debbie Johnson
3 shared
A Wedding in December
A Wedding in December
Sarah Morgan
3 shared
Amish Christmas Kitchen
Amish Christmas Kitchen
Kelly Long
3 shared
Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery
Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery
Jenny Colgan
3 shared
Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery: A Novel
Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery: A Novel
Jenny Colgan
3 shared
A Novel
Christmas at Red Robin Cottage
Sue Roberts
Christmas at Red Robin Cottage
Sue Roberts
3 shared
Christmas At Rosie Hopkins Sweetshop
Christmas At Rosie Hopkins Sweetshop
Jenny Colgan
3 shared
A Novel
Christmas Is All Around
Martha Waters
Christmas Is All Around
Martha Waters
3 shared
A Novel
Confetti at the Little Clock House on the Green
Eve Devon
Confetti at the Little Clock House on the Green
Eve Devon
3 shared
Don't Let Go
Don't Let Go
Jaci Burton
3 shared
A Novel
Harlequin Heartwarming December 2026 Box Set
Anna J. Stewart
Harlequin Heartwarming December 2026 Box Set
Anna J. Stewart, Patricia Johns, Elle Douglas, Lisa Dodson
3 shared
A Novel
Harlequin Heartwarming October 2023 Box Set
Anna J. Stewart
Harlequin Heartwarming October 2023 Box Set
Anna J. Stewart, Jeannie Watt, Cheryl Harper, Anna Grace
3 shared
Home Sweet Christmas
Home Sweet Christmas
Susan Mallery
3 shared
Hometown Valentine (Moonlight Cove #6)
Hometown Valentine (Moonlight Cove #6)
Lissa Manley
3 shared
Ivy Hill Christmas
Ivy Hill Christmas
Julie Klassen
3 shared
Lovelight Farms
Lovelight Farms
B. K. Borison
3 shared
A Novel
Make or Break at the Lighthouse B and B
Portia MacIntosh
Make or Break at the Lighthouse B and B
Portia MacIntosh
3 shared
Mistletoe and Mr. Right
Mistletoe and Mr. Right
Lyla Payne
3 shared
Mistletoe Marriage
Mistletoe Marriage
Jessica Hart
3 shared
Mixed Signals
Mixed Signals
B. K. Borison
3 shared
Mountains, memories & mistletoe
Mountains, memories & mistletoe
Janet Lee Barton, Kathleen Miller, Kathleen Y'Barbo
3 shared
One More for Christmas
One More for Christmas
Sarah Morgan
3 shared
Books like Rachel's Pudding Pantry (Pudding Pantry, Book 1) by Caroline Roberts · Steamy Shelf