SteamyShelf
Search title, author, trope⌘KSign inSign up
When I fall in love
If you loved

Books like When I fall in love.

Inspired by Susan May Warren

Romance readers who clicked with When I fall in love by Susan May Warren often reach for these next. The list is ranked by how many tropes each book shares with the original, so the further down you scroll, the looser the connection.

Unloved
Unloved
Peyton Corinne
8 shared
Across the Pond
Across the Pond
RJ Scott, VL Locey
7 shared
All Hail the Underdogs
All Hail the Underdogs
E.L. Massey
7 shared
Fair play
Fair play
Deirdre Martin
7 shared
Heated Rivalry
Heated Rivalry
Rachel Reid
7 shared
Like a Power Play
Like a Power Play
Elle Sprinkle
7 shared
Pucking Strong
Pucking Strong
Emily Rath
7 shared
Time to Shine
Time to Shine
Rachel Reid
7 shared
Tough Guy
Tough Guy
Rachel Reid
7 shared
Unsteady
Unsteady
Peyton Corinne
7 shared
Benoit
Benoit
RJ Scott, VL Locey
6 shared
Body check
Body check
Deirdre Martin
6 shared
Body Check
Body Check
Elle Kennedy
6 shared
Coast to Coast
Coast to Coast
RJ Scott, VL Locey
6 shared
Daydream
Daydream
Hannah Grace
6 shared
First Season
First Season
RJ Scott, VL Locey
6 shared
Game Changer
Game Changer
Rachel Reid
6 shared
Icebreaker
Icebreaker
A.L. Graziadei
6 shared
If You Dare
If You Dare
Harmony West
6 shared
Lessons from the Depraved
Lessons from the Depraved
Kinsley Kincaid
6 shared
Max
Max
Sawyer Bennett
6 shared
On the Line
On the Line
Victoria Denault
6 shared
Pucking Ever After
Pucking Ever After
Emily Rath
6 shared
Pucking Wild
Pucking Wild
Emily Rath
6 shared